CNN’s Monday report, “Exclusive: US intel indicates Iran developing plans to potentially detonate a dirty bomb in Washington, sources say,” racked up millions of views on social media. It wasn’t the first existential threat Americans have been handed of late.
The CNN article is paywalled, so most people never got to read the caveats: that there’s no intelligence to point to an imminent attack, that the Iranians are thinking of planning to maybe do something, and that officials are arguing over whether Tehran even has the ability to pull it off.
In other words, like Tucker Carlson’s fever dream a few weeks ago that Trump planned to nuke Iran, the dirty bomb story is a reminder that the mushroom cloud sells. It also keeps the nuclear priesthood on top. (That’s the weapons labs, the Pentagon’s nuclear planners and the arms-control experts whose budgets and relevance depend on the bomb being the ultimate threat.)
How many times can we all be doomed? When the FAA grounds every flight and the media compares it to 9/11 ad nauseam? When Microsoft goes down? When the chips are flying away to China? When customers at Chase and other big banks can’t get into their accounts? On Tuesday it was Apple’s turn. Then it was a classified NSA network.
So many supposed calamities that it’s almost funny. But it makes me wonder: who benefits from these stories, and specifically who would want to leak the Iran story?
A former senior intelligence official I talked to scoffed at CNN’s dirty bomb report, describing to me his own involvement in U.S. government contingency planning more than a decade ago, a scenario he called “identical” to what CNN reported.
He described a training exercise, overseen by the CIA, built around “an IRGC plot to spirit a dirty bomb into the U.S.” and staffed with Iranian, Pakistani, and Afghan role players. The exercise, he recalled, came on the heels of the Arab Spring and the Syrian chemical weapons crisis, which is what appears to have prompted it.
In other words, the Iranian dirty bomb in Washington has been an imaginary concern for over a decade and the subject of contingency planning for what to do in response. The key word here is contingency: as in, dependent on something else happening, no matter how unlikely. It’s a government pastime.
Nuclear anything is a guarantee of front-page coverage and social media virality, and it demands the White House’s attention. “At this time there are no credible threats to the homeland,” Trump administration spokesperson Lauren Bis told CNN, this from a White House not exactly known for underselling Iran.
In the case of the FAA outage, it is crystal clear who wins: the FAA. Though FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford says the agency is seeing “zero evidence of anything nefarious,” the Washington machine is already saying that a new generation of equipment will have to be purchased for the poor, starved agency and its antiquated equipment.
Then there’s the need to spend more on cyber everything. Whether some weakness or attack is the cause of any of the outages or not, the Washington machine is ready with its ever-winning parable: This is why we need to spend more on protecting the “critical” infrastructure. See what happens when just small portions go down?
The threat machine (and its media lapdogs) is relentless.
Sen. Josh Hawley told TMZ, “You can’t tell me it’s a coincidence,” in talking about the various outages. Trump confidante Laura Loomer informed her followers that the outages were what intelligence officials call “signaling,” a “pre-warning before a major hack or debilitating cyber attack.” A member of Congress, demanding a briefing, simply referred to the FAA disaster as a cyberattack, as though that had been established. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin went on Fox to float the idea that artificial intelligence was moving too fast for older systems to keep up. People got so jumpy that FEMA had to put out a statement reassuring the public that a routine, pre-scheduled test of the Emergency Alert System was just that.
But then, the news media was blaring just a couple of weeks ago about the Pentagon planning to build up 90 days of supplies if military bases go off-grid. One would think that such news would provoke a spate of preppers buying up everything, but then, why bother? Humanity is already doomed because of AI.
So, who leaked the dirty bomb story? And who leaked a similar story that already ran in The New York Times that Iran had a secret arsenal of chemical weapons?
The first and most likely culprit is the nuclear priesthood itself, needing to reassert dominance over Iran policy now that the Democrats are taking power, with the assumption that they will seek arms control and diplomacy to clean up after Donald Trump.
Second is the Secret Service-DHS-FBI-cyber security-critical infrastructure protection racket, guarding against the possibility of a reduction in national security spending under the Democrats.
The third possibility is the Democrats themselves, who want it to be known that despite Trump’s war and all the bombing, Iran still presents a threat, a grave one. But not so much a threat that more bombing is needed; hence WMD. That makes the implications of continuing to fight a war too dangerous.
The fourth possibility is that the Trump White House leaked it, wanting to change the narrative on the Iran war, that it was indeed necessary.
Fifth, the Israelis, who want it known not only that Iran is still a live threat, but that the goal of regime change shouldn’t be abandoned (look at how crazy they are).
Sixth, it could be the intelligence agencies, always angling to meld with the Hollywood image that they actually can see around the corner.
Seventh, it could be the Republicans, or conservatives in the administration, or the pro-war set who want you to know that any letting up our guard is fraught with danger, a counter to the second possibility. We can never spend too much on war.
On social media, the people most skeptical of the CNN story and the motivated leakers behind it are just repeating the Iraq WMD story. But then, their postings only have any bounce because, like the earlier Tucker Carlson nuclear story, they are talking about the end of the world.
2026 is coming to a close, and it was the year of the apocalypse. AI was going to end us, or save us, depending on the week. So was the war. So were the midterms. Every story arrived pre-inflated to the size of civilization itself.
In March, when all of Washington was bracing for a ground invasion of Iran, I reported that military sources told me it wasn’t going to happen. CNN’s Michael Smerconish cited the story on air, introducing me as a guy who writes “provocatively.” That’s where we are: declining to drink the Kool-Aid is the provocative position.
The incentives for jacking up threats are real. I feel them. “Dirty bomb in Washington” gets millions of views. “Contingency plan resembles 2012 training exercise” does not. Fear is what people click on, and what people click on is what pays the bills. It is hard to make a living telling readers that the thing they’re terrified of probably isn’t going to happen.
I’m trying to anyway. Subscribe if you’re sick of the fearmongering.
— Edited by William M. Arkin



Always great writing/facts. Thanks!
USA truly lost its way with the establishment of the military-industrial-surveillance complex and its continued obscene funding.
The evil bureaucracies use any excuse, concoct any lie, to justify their existence.